Samsung's first foldable phone is turning from sensation to tragedy fast.
Something is very wrong with some of the Galaxy Fold review units. On Wednesday, and seemingly within minutes of one another, four reviewers of Samsung's foldable phone posted photos of their bulging, "broken", "unusable" Folds, one with a portion of the screen white and the other half blacked out.
On Wednesday morning, Bloomberg's Mark Gurman
about his review unit: "The screen on my Galaxy Fold review unit is completely broken and unusable just two days in. Hard to know if this is widespread or not."
After one day of use... pic.twitter.com/VjDlJI45C9— Steve Kovach (@stevekovach) April 17, 2019
And CNBC's Todd Haselton experienced screen flickering on the left side of his review device. YouTube reviewer
) and The Verge's Dieter Bohn also had issues, with Bohn's screen forming a bulge beneath the surface.
PSA: There's a layer that appears to be a screen protector on the Galaxy Fold's display. It's NOT a screen protector. Do NOT remove it.— Marques Brownlee (@MKBHD) April 17, 2019
I got this far peeling it off before the display spazzed and blacked out. Started over with a replacement. pic.twitter.com/ZhEG2Bqulr
Samsung is aware of the issue. A limited number of early Galaxy Fold samples were provided to media for review. We have received a few reports regarding the main display on the samples provided. We will thoroughly inspect these units in person to determine the cause of the matter," the company said in a statement on Wednesday.
These reports of a faulty Galaxy Fold are a nightmare situation for Samsung, the first major brand to sell a foldable phone. The Fold, which has a 4.6-inch screen on the outside, a bendable 7.3-inch screen on the inside and a nearly $1,980 price tag, is a major risk for the tech giant.
Intense criticism at the outset could hurt future sales, and shake consumer confidence in the concept of foldable phones in general. The Galaxy Fold's chance to lead the emerging category could come under fire if buyers turn their backs on the innovative design, or opt for a rival model like Huawei's Mate X, TCL's upcoming designs or a rumored foldable phone like the Motorola Razr.
CNET's review unit remains intact, and there might be one specific reason why. Two of the reviewers (Gurman and Brownlee) experienced their problems when they removed a thin plastic film that runs along the Galaxy Fold's screen.
This layer is noticeable, and isn't immediately obvious if it belongs to the phone or was an extra film that you commonly see on devices to keep the screens smudge- and lint-free during shipping and storage.
I had received my review unit on Monday morning, then shot an , and worried that I had forgotten to take off this plastic layer -- what would the YouTube viewers say?! Turns out, what looks like a paper-thin sheet of plastic covering the foldable phone's 7.3-inch display is a protective layer that's crucial to helping keep the phone damage-free.
You can see the edges of that layer here, on my review unit:
Look closely and you can see a thin line hugging the screen just beyond the bezel. This is the protective layer that Samsung wants to remain firmly in place.Angela Lang/CNET
But it's not the whole story, because two other reviewers -- Haselton and Bohn, said that they didn't remove the film, and still had problems that rendered the Fold unusable. So what's going on?So far reviewers haven't indicated any truly dangerous behavior.
Video: Galaxy Fold is a foldable phone with a bendable screen
What's the deal with the Galaxy Fold's screen?
The Galaxy Fold has a completely different screen setup than any other phone. There's a 4.6-inch display on the outside that's covered with Gorilla Glass -- that's the same as other Galaxy phones like the S10 and S10 Plus ($961 at Amazon). But inside, the screen is made of a plastic (polymer) material that Samsung calls its Infinity Flex Display.
Samsung created this with a new process and specific adhesives to withstand the screen's bending and flexing without breaking. The screen protector layer is meant to remain in place to prevent damage to the display below -- that's the thing that actually makes your "screen" light up. Without the hardness of glass to cover the delicate display, the Fold is more vulnerable, something that's become vividly apparent.
Is there something different about the review phones?
Yes. Reviewers received early production models. That means these aren't the final review units, and could be prone to certain issues that Samsung might have the opportunity to fix before the Fold reaches buyers' hands.
For example, I was told that my review unit is an unlocked European version that doesn't support US services like Bixby Voice, Samsung Health and Samsung Pay. Likewise, I was warned that call quality might be compromised because the phone isn't optimized to US bands.
While I'm fully testing this review unit of the Galaxy Fold, I am withholding a rating until I receive the final production model CNET ordered.
Video: Watch Samsung's Galaxy Fold stress test
Did Samsung say you're not supposed to remove the film?
It isn't clear if Samsung thoroughly briefed every reviewer who received a phone about the screen protector layer. There was no instruction in my box -- no literature at all, in fact -- but also no other indication, like a pull tab, that you should remove it.
However, I almost did anyway. As a reviewer, I like to experience the phone as "clean" as possible. That means everything I can peel off is going to come off. I emailed Samsung for more information about this layer on Tuesday. A spokesperson responded, "Galaxy Fold is manufactured with a special protective layer. It is not a screen protector – do not attempt to remove it."
The company further elaborated its position:
A few reviewers reported having removed the top layer of the display causing damage to the screen. The main display on the Galaxy Fold features a top protective layer, which is part of the display structure designed to protect the screen from unintended scratches. Removing the protective layer or adding adhesives to the main display may cause damage. We will ensure this information is clearly delivered to our customers.
Desmond Smith, director of creative content and a tech evangelist at T-Mobile,
But peeling off the screen layer isn't the only issue
While removing the plastic film caused a problem for some, it isn't entirely clear what the protective film does or how its removal relates to the screen's behavior. Remember that two of the reviewers kept the protector on. Bohn suspects that a piece of debris may have become lodged under the screen to create the bulge he felt, and a slight distortion on the Fold's surface.
Halseton, meanwhile, observed a persistent screen flicker over the left half of the screen. We know that two batteries, one on each side, work in concert to form a single power source. I'm not an electrical or chemical engineer, but I wonder if that could indicate a battery issue. Hopefully we'll all find out one way or another.
At any rate, the Galaxy Fold's risky design has created some inconsistencies that could damage its early production phones and its reputation.
Why are bendable screens made of plastic in the first place?
Right now, glass doesn't bend so well. That's something that Corning -- the maker of Gorilla Glass, which covers most high-end phones -- is working on. Don't expect bendable glass to save second-gen foldable phones, though. It won't be ready for some time.
Video: The bendable glass that’s shaping up to cover foldable phones
If I ordered the Galaxy Fold, should I cancel it?
If you're genuinely interested in owning the Galaxy Fold, I suggest the wait-and-see approach. We don't know how widespread the issue is, and if it affects a bad batch or the entire lineup. I'm not saying don't be concerned, but let's see what develops. My own review unit hasn't experienced screen abnormalities at this point, but I'm keeping a close eye on any issues.
The reported problems make the affected Galaxy Fold unusable, but so far reviewers haven't indicated any truly dangerous behavior, unlike reports after some batteries in the ill-fated Galaxy Note 7 were found to overheat and sometimes catch fire.
Samsung won't want another PR disaster on its hands. I'm confident it would fully refund a broken Galaxy Fold if it did happen to you. Regardless, we'll hopefully get a more concrete explanation before the Galaxy Fold officially goes on sale April 26.
What is Samsung doing to fix the problem?
Samsung is well aware of the issues, and is working with reviewers to replace broken devices to investigate what went wrong (see the statements above).
In addition, we've asked Samsung what it thinks happened, if buyers can feel assured that their Folds won't break, if Samsung will provide a refund if people cancel their order, and if it will it be clear what future Fold owners should and shouldn't do to protect their phones.
We'll update this story if we hear back. In the meantime, here's how it's going with CNET's Galaxy Fold so far.
Originally published April 17, 7:55 p.m. PT.
Update, 8:24 p.m.: Adds Samsung's statement.
Update, April 18 at 6 a.m. PT: Adds more detail.